US
President Barack Obama has signaled that Canada's oil sands industry should
not be granted an exemption from strict regulations to limit emissions of
greenhouse gases.
His stance could add to the already high costs of
developing this vast resource which is increasingly regarded as one of North America's most secure sources of energy.
Obama travels to Canada on Thursday for his first
foreign visit as head of state. During his campaign for the presidency he
pledged to fight global warming through implementation of a carbon tax or
creation of a carbon emissions market.
Energy will be one of the main topics of discussion
between Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Obama. Harper is expected to
urge the US
president not to impose strict environmental regulations on high-carbon sources
of energy like oil sands and coal, because it could make them unprofitable to
produce.
"What we know is that oil sands create a big
carbon footprint," Obama said in a television interview with the Canadian
Broadcasting Corporation Tuesday. "I think that it is possible for us to
create a set of clean energy mechanisms that allow us to use things not just
like oil sands, but also coal. The United States
is the Saudi Arabia
of coal, but we have our own homegrown problems in terms of dealing with a
cheap energy source that creates a big carbon footprint."
Canada
is the biggest foreign supplier of oil to the US,
and in recent years a growing share of that oil has been derived from the oil
sands region of northern Alberta
which are estimated to hold a massive 173 billion
barrels of oil.
About 780,000 barrels of oil per day are produced from
the Alberta oil sands and exported to the US. Canada
currently sells about 60% of its oil sands output to US refiners.
Converting the bitumen extracted from the oil sands
into gasoline and diesel fuel takes about 20% percent more energy -- and
generates a correspondingly larger amount of carbon emissions -- than using
conventional crude.
With that in mind, environmentalists on both sides of
the border have been calling on Obama to honor his past pledges to rein in
carbon emissions.
"He doesn't come out and say there will be a
dispensation," said David Biette, director of
the Canada Institute in Washington.
"He seems to put all energy sources into the same arena."
During the CBC interview, Obama called on Canada and the US to invest more in advanced
technology that could capture carbon and store it underground.
"All of us are going to have to work together in
an effective way to figure out how we balance the imperatives of economic
growth with very real concerns about the effect we're having on our
planet," Obama said. "And ultimately I think this can be solved by
technology."
The White House and Democratic leaders in Congress are
pushing aggressively to pass legislation that would either impose a carbon tax
on fuels or create a carbon trading system that would cap US carbon emissions.
Either approach would increase the cost of producing
oil from the Alberta
oil sands, which is mined from the earth as bitumen or heated and pumped to the
surface. The higher greenhouse gas emissions associated with the oil sands are
caused in large part by the energy used to separate the oil out from the sand
and other impurities.
The recent steep fall in oil prices to current levels
of around $40 a barrel have already had a big impact on plans to expand Canadian oil sands production.
Canadian bank TD Newcrest calculates that around
600,000 b/d of new output, originally scheduled to come on stream by 2010 or
2011, has been postponed.
Bill Murray, Washington
For comprehensive coverage
and analysis of US
energy policy, visit Energy Intelligence's special web portal, Obama Energy
Vision, at www.energyintel.com/obama.